"In most cases, radical movements are quite unchallenged as they use the web to promote their views and policies."-David Livingstone
In the article "Taking on the Radicals," David Livingstone refers to a group of young British Muslims who were charged with terrorist acts after discovery of radical, Islamic-related material was found on each of their respective computers. Destructive action was not taken by any member of the aforementioned group, so it would seem that the question now becomes one of the appropriateness of censorship to potentially stop trouble before it begins.
A fine line exists between freedom of speech and the protection of innocents. Should the internet employ a type of policing/censorship system to block perceived harmful materials, or should the internet remain a conduit for the free exchange of ideas? Livingstone enumerates the many difficulties of trying to introduce censorship into the web and chat rooms, bemoaning the near impossibility of policing the enormity of cyberspace. Livingstone instead brings forth a new set of ideas such as a "web-engagement" strategy that would depict real world events to discourage individuals from subscribing to "fringe" or radical ideals.
In any case, development of a strategy to curtail terrorist acts is not only encouraged, but (unfortunately) necessary if we wish to continue to enjoy a peaceful existence.
Reference:
Livingstone, D. (2007) Taking on the radicals. Censorship. 36 (4),148-153.
Retrieved from Ebsco database May 25, 2010.
2 comments:
Tough call! We want our freedom of speech and First Amendment rights, but I think we have to balance the right with protections.
Sir Tim-Berners Lee imagined an Internet free of protection. Hmmm... but did he imagine the type of cyber terrorism that is occurring?
Your thoughts?
I had Berners-Lee in mind when writing this post. Berners-Lee envisioned an easily accessible, information sharing conduit, but I doubt he had this sort of (potentially lethal) information sharing in mind.
Thanks for the comment!
Post a Comment